Impossible pie is so named because all the ingredients are mixed together in one bowl and then ‘miraculously’ separate into three layers in the oven, giving a soft pie base, a creamy custard filling and a crunchy coconut topping. Sounds impossible but it works every time! The recipe seems to have originated in the USA in the 1970s, based on a southern coconut custard pie. I made my first version over 30 years ago, from a Women’s Weekly Cookbook (the source of so many of my favourite recipes) and I’ve been experimenting ever since to come up with the perfect combination of flavours; so far almond and orange impossible pie is the best! I found an equally surprising wine match to serve with it, plum wine (umeshu), a slightly sweet Japanese liqueur, served on the rocks it works a treat! See the video below for another easy Southern classic.

Serves 6

Ingredients
  • ½ cup plain flour, sifted
  • 1 cup castor sugar
  • 1 cup shredded coconut
  • 125g butter, melted, plus extra for greasing
  • 4 eggs, lightly beaten
  • 1½ cups milk
  • 1 orange, zested
  • ⅓ cup orange juice
  • 2 tablespoons Disaronno amaretto liqueur 
Method
  1. Preheat oven to 170ºC.
  2. Combine all Ingredients.
  3. Pour into a lightly greased 1-litre pie dish.
  4. Bake for 40-50 minutes, until well coloured and set in the centre.
  5. Serve warm or cold. 

Share page on:

Southern Buttermilk Biscuits

Join Me Soon

What Other Cooks Say

Melisa (Beacon Hill, NSW)
Melisa (Beacon Hill, NSW)
Read More
We made the pot-sticker dumplings and bang bang chicken from the Chinese class the other night. Once again both exceeded our expectations. My husband keeps saying it’s better than going out to restaurants as the recipes and quality are amazing.
Glennis (Caringbah South, NSW)
Glennis (Caringbah South, NSW)
Read More
The whole Be Inspired experience has helped me love cooking again. I was sick of cooking the same old things - meal time is a lot brighter thanks to you Roberta.
Pam (Cammeray, NSW)
Pam (Cammeray, NSW)
Read More
Your recipes are something I always feel confident offering guests and also reasonable in the time to prepare. We often try your recommended wines and suppliers and enjoy your travel tales too!
Jen (Tamarama, NSW)
Jen (Tamarama, NSW)
Read More
Thank you for stocking our pantry with such authentic Ingredients and quality produce. We really like the flexibility of cooking over a couple of days and changing the order we cook the dishes in when we want to. And I love listening to the themed playlist while cooking.
Katrina (Arncliffe, NSW)
Katrina (Arncliffe, NSW)
Read More
I am absolutely loving Be Inspired! There are ingredients I have never worked with before so having the confidence to try something new is so much fun! The recipes are just amazing and the notes on what can be prep’d beforehand are a great help too. Thank you so much.
Deb (Belconnen, ACT)
Deb (Belconnen, ACT)
Read More
Awesome fun traveling through Emilia-Romagna experiencing first hand some of the produce I've worked with over the last couple of years cooking with Roberta's classes – the family are reaping the benefits now.
Judith (Woronora, NSW)
Judith (Woronora, NSW)
Read More
Food, wine and travel! Three of my favourite things! Be Inspired with Roberta has been a wonderful experience and given me more confidence in the kitchen. I have learnt so much, cooked things I never would have attempted without Roberta’s excellent videos, and used ingredients I have never tried before.
Sandra (Garran, ACT)
Sandra (Garran, ACT)
Read More
I'm a competent cook whose learned so much from Roberta's online cooking classes. The recipes are yummy and Roberta’s video guidance offers so many little tips to improve flavour and organise the flow of preparation. I enjoy her warmth, sense of humour, and ability to giggle at herself when she occasionally messes up.
Previous
Next

FAQ

Why is impossible pie impossible?

Impossible pie is so named because all the Ingredients are mixed together in one bowl and then ‘miraculously’ separate into three layers in the oven, giving a soft pie base, a creamy custard filling and a crunchy coconut topping. Sounds impossible but it works every time!

Where did impossible pie originate?

Impossible pie seems to have originated in the USA in the 1970s, based on a southern coconut custard pie.

Is impossible pie sweet or savoury?

While most recipes for impossible pie are sweet, the technique works just as well for savoury versions.

What's the best flavouring for impossible pie?

I’ve been experimenting for many years to come up with the perfect combination of flavours; so far orange and almond impossible pie is the best I’ve found.

What's the best wine match for impossible pie?

Try Japanese plum wine (umeshu), a slightly sweet Japanese liqueur with orange and almond impossible pie.

Subscribe To My Newsletter & Get A Free Online Italian Cooking Class (RRP $39)