Fettuccine Alfredo is the simplest of pasta dishes, and the one that proves the supreme importance of pasta cooking water as the secret ingredient in any pasta sauce. This classic Italian pasta is named for Alfredo di Lelio, a Roman restaurateur who popularised it at Ristorante Alfredo in the 1920s, where it was theatrically prepared tableside. Today his grandchildren run the second iteration of his restaurant, Il Vero Alfredo, still serving their Nonno’s famous pasta. Pasta with butter and cheese is nothing new of course and has long been known as fettuccine al burro or, when very rich, fettuccine al triplo burro (fettuccine with triple butter). Call it what you will, what makes fettuccine Alfredo more than just buttered noodles with cheese is the emulsifying magic of the starchy pasta cooking water. Many of my Italian chef friends call it the ‘secret sauce’ as adding a little to any pasta gives a lovely creamy sheen. For traditional fettuccine Alfredo you’ll use about 1 cup of pasta cooking water to emulsify the butter and cheese into a smooth, creamy sauce that clings to every strand of fettuccine. It’s also the only seasoning the dish needs, so be sure to add enough salt to the water (see video below for all you need to know about cooking pasta like a Nonna). In America, pasta Alfredo has evolved into a different recipe containing cream, which is never used in authentic Italian fettuccine Alfredo. So you’ll need to decide whether you’re making the classic Italian version, or the newer American one. I suggest trying Italian fettuccine Alfredo first and then deciding if it really needs the cream. You can luxe up this simple dish by making truffle pasta Alfredo. Aussie chardonnay is a great match for fettuccine Alfredo, especially one like Domaine Naturaliste Discovery from Margaret River with its buttery chardonnay nose and crisp refreshing palate.

Serves 4 as a starter

Ingredients
  • 25g cooking salt (1oz)
  • 250g dried fettuccine (9oz)
  • 65g butter (2⅓oz)
  • 65g Parmigiano-Reggiano or Grana Padano, finely grated (2⅓oz)
Method
  1. Place 2.5 litres (5 pints) of water in a large saucepan, add salt and bring to the boil.
  2. Add pasta and cook until just al dente, using packet instructions as a guide.
  3. Meanwhile, melt butter in a large frying pan over low heat then set aside.
  4. When pasta is almost cooked, add ¼ cup (60ml) of the pasta cooking water to the butter and simmer over a high heat, shaking the pan frequently until it’s emulsified and slightly thickened. Reduce heat to low and let it simmer.
  5. Use tongs to transfer the cooked pasta into the frying pan then turn off the saucepan’s heat.
  6. Increase heat under frying pan to medium and toss the pasta for 30 seconds or so until the butter mixture has been absorbed.
  7. Add a quarter of the cheese and another ¼ cup of pasta cooking water and continue tossing and stirring vigorously with the tongs until well combined.
  8. Add half the remaining cheese and another ¼ cup of pasta cooking water and toss and stir until incorporated.
  9. Add most of the remaining cheese, reserving a little for garnish, and another ¼ cup or so of pasta cooking water and keep mixing to create a smooth, thick sauce coating the pasta.
  10. Transfer into warmed shallow bowls, sprinkle with remaining cheese and serve fettuccine Alfredo immediately.

Share page on:

How To Cook Pasta Like A Nonna

What Other Travellers Say

Diane (Cremorne Point, NSW, Aus)
Diane (Cremorne Point, NSW, Aus)
Relaxed, organised and well-paced – a wonderful bespoke small group tour, starting in Rome, then travelling down the Amalfi Coast to stay at a family estate where we were treated like old friends. This tour included some hidden gems too, notably on our way to Matera, a fascinating town built into the side of a mountain. We finished with Naples and Pompeii – with plenty of wine and more new tastes. Roberta is a specialist and very personable as she hosts and explains every detail of the food and wine experience.
Belinda (Balmain, NSW, Aus)
Belinda (Balmain, NSW, Aus)
I’ve been on three of Roberta’s food and wine tours so far and each one has been an amazing well-organised experience. From historic Rome and Pompeii to the spectacular Amalfi Coast, remarkable Venice and the charming villages of Switzerland, each tour offers something special. Then there’s the food in fabulous places where you can truly eat like a local. I highly recommend Roberta’s tours to anyone who wants to discover inspired travel through great food, wine and company. I’m already looking forward to the next one!
Michael (Cremorne, NSW, Aus)
Michael (Cremorne, NSW, Aus)
Starting in Rome then spending time on the Amalfi Coast and further south before heading back to Rome for the last couple of days made for a nice ‘round trip’. Roberta’s choice of eateries was excellent with some very enjoyable meals – and a nice mix of other activities, like vineyard visits, between meals. Everything was very well organised: transport, nice hotels in close proximity to most activities, and a relaxed pace with enough time to follow your nose if that took your fancy. A very worthwhile tour and I’m already looking forward to another!
Di (Manly, NSW, Aus)
Di (Manly, NSW, Aus)
I absolutely recommend Roberta’s Southern Italy tour! We’ve always been independent travellers so were a little apprehensive – by day 2 we knew we’d made a great decision! Roberta knows people and places far from the tourist trail so we visited wineries where we were always invited for lunch as well as wine-tasting, a family lemon grove high on the Amalfi Coast and a 3rd generation cheesemaker. We stayed in a stunning cave hotel in Matera and a gorgeous family hotel in Scala – and book-ended the tour with the vibrancy of Rome. So many highlights, such a brilliant experience. We will do another tour with Roberta.
Neville (St Ives, NSW, Aus)
Neville (St Ives, NSW, Aus)
We had an absolutely fantastic time in Southern Italy and Rome with Roberta. Incredible food and wine experiences combined with authentic cultural encounters, fascinating history and breathtaking scenery. From the charming streets of Trastevere and the stunning Amalfi Coast to Matera, Pompeii and the hidden gems of Basilicata, every day brought something memorable. Meeting local winemakers, farmers, chefs and families who welcomed us with genuine warmth made this trip exceptional. Roberta's passion for Italy, attention to detail, warmth, knowledge and care for every guest made the experience unforgettable. We will gladly travel with Roberta again.
Subscribe To My Newsletter & Get A Free Online Italian Cooking Class (RRP $39)